Brooklyn Rail Yard Fight

11 July 2005 - 11:00am

Peter Slatin interviews a reclusive developer who's competing towin a major Brooklyn development site.

"Leveraging community displeasure over the unruly scope of Forest City Ratner's $3.5 billion, 21-acre plan for the Atlantic Rail Yards in Brooklyn, Gary Barnett's Extell Development Co. submitted a rival, 11th-hour bid for the site to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Although Barnett's is proposing to build one-third of the housing that Forest City Ratner envisions, sources close to Extell claim that their bid price may exceed that of the more firmly entrenched opposing bid... The competing proposals reflect starkly contrasting development philosophies and divergent approaches to the Brooklyn neighborhoods in question.Unlike the Forest City plan, Extell's development scope is restricted entirely to the Atlantic Yards site, and so does not impinge on existing property or require seizure of private land under eminent domain."

Full Story: Yard Fight
Source: The Slatin Report, July 8, 2005
Bookmark and Share
Even if the report overestimates the costs by a factor of two and underestimates the tax-benefit by a similar amount, the conclusion would be pretty much the same: destination resorts cost local government and taxpayers money.