Is Gentrification Really A Threat?

6 June 2005 - 7:00am

Should the social virtues of urbanism and new investment in cities get washed out in the hue and cry over gentrification?

"With urban living regaining popularity, reinvestment has spread to some of the smaller markets, as has the concern about displacement or gentrification.

...The social virtues of urbanism and the cost-benefit discussion of new investment in cities tend to get washed out in the hue and cry over "gentrification" when some local activists, CDCs and armchair liberals assume the heroic mantle of protectors of the poor. While their outrage at urban developers is no doubt self-gratifying, it presents the existing residents of urban neighborhoods a very distorted picture of the costs and benefits of potential redevelopment."

John Norquist is President of the Congress for the New Urbanism, which holds its annual Congress in Pasadena from June 9-12

Source: Planetizen, June 6, 2005
Bookmark and Share
It is hard to think of a starker contrast than that between Moses modernism and Jacobs localism. Yet the standoff between Jacobs and Moses only ever sparred two separate wings of the middle class concerning how to build and rebuild the city for people of greater rather than lesser class privilege.