British Voters Give Congestion Charging A Big Setback

27 February 2005 - 7:00am

A key plank of British transport policy meets with public resistance in Edinburgh.

In 2000, the British Labour party's 10-year transport plan envisaged that 20 urban areas would introduce tolls for drivers within a decade, pursuing a vision of smog-free, pedestrian-friendly towns and cities. So far, only central London and a single street in Durham have done so. After yesterday's vote in Edinburgh, even keen advocates of congestion charging admitted that other cities would be hard pushed to take the political risk. An advisor to an MP who had strongly backed the plan bemoaned Edinburgh's fickle voters yesterday: "I've lost faith in democracy. Just because the public don't like things doesn't mean they're wrong." [Editor's note: Also see "Edinburgh says no to road toll"]

Source: The Guardian Unlimited, February 23, 2005
Bookmark and Share
All of that only scratches the surface of what's wrong with this study. The idea that complex urban development patterns and human behavior can be meaningfully studied according to one primary criteria — density — is wrong from the start.