When Does A Liquor Store Become A Nuisance?

9 November 2004 - 1:00pm

Neighborhood residents find that closing an unruly local liquor store -- is a lesson in planning gone awry.

The fundamental question of what constitues a nuisance is examined, with desires of neighbors to limit dangerous activity are weighed against a city's desire to remain business-friendly:

"For more than two years, neighbors of Al's Liquors spent day and night documenting problems at the store. They risked their lives confronting drug dealers. They waded through drunken loiterers who blocked sidewalks and threatened them. They called the police nonemergency number too many times to count, just to make sure the problems were being documented somewhere.

But despite their efforts and recommendations from the city attorney and the California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, a hearing officer's revocation decision was overruled by the Planning Commission in September."

Source: The Oakland Tribune, November 8, 2004
Bookmark and Share
I am perfectly willing to risk the attacks of the traffic planners when I insist that the solution to coexistence of the human and automotive population does not lie in the taming and training of people, but in the taming of the motorcar.