Is L.A. More Crowded Than New York?

In "L.A. the King of Sprawl, Not at All," Robert Bruegmann reports that Los Angeles is one of the densest areas in the country. His article reinforces the notion that L.A. is already a very dense place, but is it true?

Three UCLA students investigate the issue, and find:

"While it is true that the urbanized area of Los Angeles has a higher population density than the urbanized area of Los Angeles, our analysis shows that the City of Los Angeles is much less dense than the City of New York. The analysis presented here aids in dismantling the perception that Los Angeles’ density exceeds that of New York and should be the reason for limiting development in the City of Los Angeles. It is disingenuous to compare density figures by "urbanized area," as doing so lacks the necessary apples-toapples comparison quality. Instead, we argue that discussions about density should focus on more reasonably defined urban areas, such as proper city limit boundaries as presented in this paper.

Thanks to Livable Places Email Newsletter

Full Story: Is L.A. More Crowded Than New York?

Comments

Comments

er...sort of.

I think this report and presentation sort of miss the point. Although I do think that using sheer population density to suggest that LA may be less sprawling than New York is misleading on the part of Bruegmann, I don't think that just comparing the density within city boundaries only is a valid refutation due to the geographical and structural differences between eastern and western cities, and the fact that the author indeed intended to compare urbanized regions, not just central cities. Urbanized areas are not, as the authors of this presentation imply, some vague abstraction used for statistical trickery but very real, very tangible, and very useful boundaries of the 'built-up' area of a city and its suburbs. Here's what I think better refutes Bruegmann:

Population density as a measure of sprawl works, up to a point. What it doesn't measure is the degree to which land uses are separated, the degree of clustering, the degree of centrality of a particular area, connectivity of the street grid, and other measurable traits that determine whether a place is built in a conventional automobile-oriented way, or if it subscribes to emerging best practices in planning. A 5-squre mile walled housing subdivision with 6 houses per acre, access via a single six-lane arterial road with no transit or shopping for several miles in any direction in Southern California will indeed show up as being of 'higher density' than, say, a town in Central New Jersey with one-acre zoning, but walking distance to shops and a train station. Of these two, which one would you consider "sprawl?"

Both

Of these two, which one would you consider "sprawl?"

Both of them..

Prepare for the AICP Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $199
Planetizen Courses image ad

Planetizen Courses

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning professional.
Starting at $14.95 a month
poster

A Short History of America

From comic book artist Robert Crumb, poster shows how the built environment has changed throughout the decades.
$14.95
Book cover of Where Things Are from Near to Far

Where Things Are From Near to Far

This engaging children's book about planning illustrates that "every building has its place."
$19.95