If I'm eating chowdah I must be in Boston

Lisa Feldstein's picture

One of the ways we identify places is by foods for which those places are known. Baltimore – crab. Maine – lobster. Cincinnati – chili. San Francisco – sourdough bread. Vienna – pastry. Even for a city to which you've never been, chances are that in your mind that city has some food association.

I thought about this last week, while on a food tour of Harlem during the annual conference of the Association for the Study of Food and Society. We spent hours walking through the neighborhoods of Harlem, tracing its evolution through food. The barely visible traces of when East Harlem was home to the largest concentration of Italians outside Italy, and the rapidly fading presence of Puerto Rican cuchifritos (fried snacks, usually pig skin) and pasteles (a tamale-like holiday food). The agua frescas brought by the Mexican influx of the last fifteen years, and the African merchants selling palm fruit oil, fufu (cassava flour), cola nuts, and elubo (yam flour). The papayas and plantains that are consumed by the West Indians as well as many of the other people who have settled in Harlem. And of course, fried chicken, ribs, and greens with macaroni and cheese; a soul food feast that ties Black Harlem to its southern American roots.

And yet, if we played the city – food word association game, I'm guessing these are not the foods that would have been named. New York – bagels. New York – pizza. New York – hot dogs (from a stand on a street corner, natch). New York – weak diner coffee in an iconic Anthora to-go cup, emblazoned with the slogan "We are happy to serve you". New York – black & white cookies. New York – Mister Softee ice cream trucks.

The foods that are associated with New York have been disassociated from their cultural roots. To be sure, we know pizza is Italian and bagels are Jewish, but even so tagged, we are inclined to think: "Jewish bagels are something you eat in New York". They have become a New York food, understood to be iconic of the city. Yet cuchifritos remain steadfastly Puerto Rican not New York, even though I'd wager they are more widely available than New York cheesecake.

Food is one of the many ties we have to place. It is an indicator. If I'm standing on a street corner eating a soft, hot pretzel or a cool Italian ice I know I'm in New York. Yet if I'm standing on that same corner savoring a spicy Jamaican meat pie, though I'm consuming the food of one of New York's many cultures, there is nothing about eating that meat pie that places me in New York. The people of the nearly infinite ethnic subcultures that have and continue to make up New York's polyglot neighborhoods are celebrating their ancestral culture, not their identities as New Yorkers, when eating Dominican arepas (a fat cornmeal griddle cake, often filled with meat or cheese). If those arepas are transmogrified into knishes, then the consumers become New Yorkers, or are celebrating New York.

How do these distinctions play into identity? To our understandings of what it means to belong? To how we map place? 

Lisa Feldstein seeks to use land use as a tool for social and economic justice.



It may take time

It may take time for an ethnic food to be identified with place. The Jews and Italians started arriving in NYC over 100 years ago. And bagels and pizza were not that widely known until much later.

Also, instead of just a few ethnic groups with their distinctive foods, we now have many such groups, which may make it harder for one such food to stand out. Especially if the group has settled in many places across the country.

Michael Lewyn's picture

pretzels + ice + Philly

"If I’m standing on a street corner eating a soft, hot pretzel or a cool Italian ice I know I’m in New York."

I think a million-plus Philadelphians would contest that statement!

Lisa Feldstein's picture

pretzels + ice + Philly

Fair enough!

Philly foods

Hi, Lisa -- Michael's comment was exactly the one I, as a native Philadelphian, was going to make. We don't want those New Yorkers taking over our signature traditions! And on that pretzel, you need to squeeze bright yellow mustard that is sure to get all over you.

Philadelphia Vs. New York

As long as you Philadelphians don't claim that you invented Horn & Hardardt Automats, I (as a native New Yorker) won't complain.

PS: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horn_%26_Hardart

Charles Siegel

Lisa Feldstein's picture

It may take time

Good points. At the same time, African-Americans have been in New York since its beginnings as New Amsterdam, and certainly had brought soul food to NYC by the end of the Civil War. On the other hand, kebobs are popular street food in NYC, yet the cultures with which kebobs are associated have never had a major presence in NY.

Food and cities

Reared on ethnic food because it was cheap, that is if you ate standing up. And what is that popular phrase: the world is my bagel.

Prepare for the AICP* Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $245

Essential Readings in Urban Planning

Planning on taking the AICP* Exam? Register for Planetizen's AICP * Exam Preparation Course to save $25.
Book cover of Unsprawl

Unsprawl: Remixing Spaces as Places

Explore visionary, controversial and ultimately successful strategies for building people-centered places.
Starting at $12.95

City Map Posters are in!

Available in 9 different cities.