An Argument for Housing Choice

Trying to thread the needle between those who celebrate the demise of the exurb and those who bemoan smart growth policies, Edward Glaeser argues that we can, and should, have it all when it comes to housing choice in America.

Rather than picking sides in the sprawl versus density debate, Glaeser argues for the importance of all of the above:

"Economic theory typically embraces choice, whether in supermarkets or in cities. It is a great thing that Americans can opt to live in dense cities or sprawling suburbs. As long as people pay the social costs of their actions, and are not subsidized by policies that artificially favor one living style over another, then it is splendid that we have plenty of options, some with sunshine and inexpensive mass-produced housing and others with high wages and costly apartments."

The crucial caveat in the above statement should not go unnoticed, as it serves as the front line in the debate between the supporters of sprawl and density. Rather than getting caught up in current skirmishes, however, Glaeser frames the debate in larger historical terms:

"The tides of history may occasionally make one form of living appear temporarily triumphant -- as suburbia did, thanks to cheap cars and abundant highways, in the 1960s and 1970s -- but soon enough other forces reassert themselves. After 1980, globalization and new technologies increased the value of ideas and innovation, which in turn led to a rebirth of those older, denser cities that were heavy with human capital."

In the end, Glaeser offers suggestions to ameliorate the worst side effects of each development type:

"Cities such as New York, Boston and San Francisco, where prices have stayed reasonably high, despite the crash, should do more to promote affordable housing, especially by eliminating the barriers to new construction."

"Cities such as Dallas and Houston are doing well with their low-cost pro-business model, but history has been less kind to less-educated places. They should be investing more in education and in urban amenities that will attract the more skilled."

"The biggest challenges are in the places like Merced and Detroit that have too much housing relative to the level of demand. These places have too little education, and lack the industrial strength that holds up Houston. These areas should at least focus on educating their children and creating a more business-friendly environment."

Full Story: You Hate Taxes, but You’re Not Moving to Nashville

Comments

Comments

Glaeser the Economist

Once again, Glaeser shows that he thinks like an economist, not like an environmentalist or an urban designer.

His take on the city has always been that height limits are a primarily question of supply, demand, and price, not of urban design. (He is willing to make a concession to design for some special places that aleady exist, such as a small area of central Paris, but if we follow his advice, we will never build that sort of special place again.)

Now, he has the same sort of take on suburbia: he takes the typical economist's approach of internalizing externalities, which is good as far as it goes, but which leaves out many of the most important things about building livable suburbs - such as a connected street grid and mixed uses within walking distance of each other. Because he doesn't think of these design issues, he claims the sort of suburbs we have been building in Dallas or Houston are perfectly okay, if they just had taxes to internalize externalities and spent more on education to boost their economic growth.

Compare him with the New Urbanists. By contrast to Glaeser's laissez-faire approach to cities, they have shown that we can create attractive urban designs by using form-based codes to create consistent fabric buildings. By contrast to Glaeser's laissez-faire-plus-externalities approach to suburbs, they have shown that we can create more livable, walkable suburbs.

Charles Siegel

Prepare for the AICP Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $199
Planetizen Courses image ad

Planetizen Courses

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning professional.
Starting at $14.95 a month
DVD Cover of The Story of Sprawl

The Story of Sprawl

See how America changed shape in this collection of historic films that visually document how sprawl evolved.
$29.99 for 2-DVD SET
Book cover of the Guide to Graduate Planning Programs 2012

Thinking about Grad School?

You need the essential resource for prospective planning students
Starting at $24.95