Board Games for Urban Planners

Mark Ferrall is on a mission to get planners away from their computer screens and collaborating again - over a good board game. Here, he presents three he thinks you and your colleagues will enjoy.

The city, since Monopoly's success, has remained a recurring feature of the modern game. For better or worse, the city is instantly available for conceptual miniaturization and is an easy target for caricature. The name of a city alone might carry an implied sense of ire, admiration, or adventure. Indeed, many planners were first exposed to planning concepts in games like Sim City. Planners are the types to enjoy multifaceted problems, a staple of computer games. Required to balance competing public, private, and political interests, we understand that there are no simple solutions. Games offer an accessible battleground for solving these types of complex problems. Even as children, that mindset drew planners to the games we grew up enjoying.

Now, the planner's lunch hour is victim to the digital age, crumbs in front of a computer screen replacing the office break room. Though blogs offer endless quality content for urbanists, they overestimate the productive social value of the comment thread. Moreover, digital games, once an entertaining alternative to the real world, have become part of the 32-bit dystopia chipping at our lives.

My challenge to planners is simple: reclaim your lunch period. Board games offer opportunities for conversation beyond the gratuitous "how was your weekend" and are a medium for the social support structure necessary to birth and implement great ideas. Ticket to Ride, Carcassonne, and Puerto Rico are entertaining games sure to get your planning geek on.

Ticket to Ride

Released in 2004 by Days of Wonder, Ticket To Ride is a cross-country card collection and route building game. The concept is simple; players collect train cards of various colors, and trade those cards to connect cities on a map. Players score points by placing trains and connecting destinations on Ticket Cards. For example, a ticket card might require a player to connect Miami and Los Angeles, and the player directs trains through combinations of other city-to-city routes to complete that ticket.

Ticket to Ride's fun factor comes from the palpable uncertainty you feel as players compete for routes. While some might choose to focus on their own tickets and avoid crossing tracks, other players ruthlessly claim short segments vital for a competitor's connections.

Planners will enjoy this game for the opportunity to build their own cross country rail scheme. The efficiency minded might build a starbursting hub-and-spoke system, while others create complex winding paths competing for the coveted longest rail card. The game takes only minutes to learn, yet has plenty of replay value. Most games take 45 minutes to an hour.

Planning Grade: B
Planning Themes: Transportation, Infrastructure Privatization, Rail

Carcassonne

Transportation not your thing? Check out Carcassonne. This game is best for those who have played a European Style board game or two, and is easiest to learn with someone who has played before. The game was initially published in 2000 by Hans im Glück in German and Rio Grande Games in English. Carcassonne is a board building game, where play consists of strategically placing board pieces. Tiles have three types of land uses: cities, roads, and farms. As players lay tiles, they can place wooden figures (Meeples!) one of the three land uses to claim portions of the board. Points are scored as other tiles are used to complete the boundaries of cities and the endpoints of roads.

There is a slight learning curve to Carcassone, but worth the wait to combine the serendipity of a card game with the strategy of a chess game. Inexperienced players regularly corner themselves into needing a specific road or city piece. Over time, players learn to control large sections of the board and clandestinely steal points from an opponent.

While the urbanism on display is simplistic, the physical arrangement of tiles will feel somehow familiar to many planners. Players must balance the size and connectivity of their cities, roads, and farms, or risk losing points. By far the prettiest game of the three; by the end every finished board will be unique.

Planning Grade: A
Themes: Land Use Planning, Zoning

Puerto Rico

If board game quality is directly proportional to the number of pieces, then Puerto Rico is king. It is the most difficult game to learn of the three, but a solid understanding of the rules reveals a complex game with endless replay value. The game was released in 2002 by Alea in Germany and published in English by Rio Grande Games.

In Puerto Rico, players are competing governors trying to settle the new city San Juan. Your plantations give you crops, crops get shipped to the main land for doubloons, doubloons buy you buildings. Both buildings and plantations require colonists in order to produce. Players collect victory points to win the game, scored by trading crops and buying buildings.

Each round provides one player the chance to be the governor while the other players take their turn. During a turn, players choose a role with corresponding actions that each player must follow. Those roles include: settler, builder, mayor, craftsman, trader, captain, prospector. For example, when the builder role is chosen players take turns buying buildings. The player who chooses the role obtains a special advantage, often buying or producing at a improved rate. Buildings offer certain advantages, for example the hospice building gives a player a colonist for when placing a new building or plantation.

Multiple methods to end the game give additional depth to Puerto Rico. The game finishes when players run out of colonists to add to the board, a player claims the last victory point, or one player fills their entire board. Players can adapt their strategy to take advantage of a probable game ending, or force the game to end earlier as a way to prevent opponents from scoring points.

It sounds complicated, and maybe it is, but Puerto Rico provides office chair game-philosophers endless combinations of strategy. The excellent replay value keeps the game from getting old, and the game is a good choice to stretch between two or three lunchbreaks.

Planning Themes: Economic Development, Food Systems Planning
Planning Grade: B+


Mark Ferrall, a recent graduate from Eastern Michigan University's undergraduate planning program, discovered his love for urbanism after being dropped in the "big city" of Ann Arbor from rural West Michigan. He brings his planning and GIS skills to the Washtenaw Area Transportation Study as a Transportation Planning Intern. When not at work, Mark spends most of his time coaxing the nature of the world from a single city, and daydreaming about mobile technology.

Comments

Comments

Board Games for Planners

Mark, thanks for this great post as I'm a sucker for "planning" board games. Out of three that you listed, I haven't played Puerto Rico but I will now probably go find it on Amazon. One of my favorites to play is The Settlers of Catan. Each player attempts to build and develop their settlement with roads while trading and acquiring resources (bricks, wheat, wood, etc.). I won't give too much more away but its all about strategy.

Don't forget Advanced Civilization!

Advanced Civilization, published in the US by Avalon Hill and now sadly out of print, is another great game about the history of human settlement. Do I use my civilization points to buy Medicine or Military? Do I engage in a lasting war against my neighbor, even though it will slow my civilization's development? Do I buy Roadbuilding, which allows people to move faster around the board, but also hastens the spread of disease (Epidemic) and dangerous ideas (Iconoclasm and Heresy)?

It's similar to Puerto Rico in terms of making strategic decisions in response to the current situation and what your neighbors are doing, but with additional layers. The only downside is that you really need at least five people for a good game, and those people have to commit to at least 6 to 8 hours. Like many other complicated board games, it helps if you're in a cold-weather state.

Power Grid

I have another suggestion. The board game is called Power Grid and it is published in English by Rio Grande Games.

The premise is that the player is in charge of a national electrical utility that is in competition with other players' companies, all of which are striving to make connections between major cities in order to supply them with electricity. There are a variety of types of power plants of varying outputs which rely on different fuel, such as coal, oil, uranium, or natural gas. Players bid on the cards that represent the power plants, which also include hydro and wind options that require no fuel, and the price for these cards is determined by its base cost and then the highest bidder.

There is a marketplace where one buys units of fuel for the non-renewable power plants and it is here that one of the most compelling elements of the game comes into play. The units of fuel in the marketplace become progressively more expensive as they are purchased and the available supply decreases. Because of this there is a real advantage to having a generating capacity that relies on multiple types of fuel and renewable soures, which require no fuel, are naturally very compelling and command a premium price when they come up for auction. Players receive income from the cities to which they supply power and in addition to the purchase of power plants and fuel, players must also pay for city access and the construction of transmission lines between them.

It's an entertaining game which can comfortably be played in 60 to 90 minutes, depending on the number of players. There is a minor degree of luck in the order in which power plant cards are revealled for auction, but otherwise it is a game that requries forethought and a degree of financial competency, especially when four to five players are in competition for an over-subscribed type of fuel and you have to undertake a wholesale reorganization of your company's generating profile just to be able to remain competitive.

The game is in stores now, plus it comes with a reversable map that offers players the choice of playing on the continental United States or within the borders of Germany.

A couple more games with an Urban Planning focus

Hi Mark...great post. Thanks for starting this thread. I own and enjoy all three of the games you mention, especially Carcassonne.

Two more games I own with even more of a city building focus but with the same "build your board" aspect are SimCity-The Card Game and Infinite City. SimCity uses playing card style cards to play with, while Infinite city has Carcassonne-style tiles, though these are larger. I am attaching links to a website that gives reviews and descriptions of the games below. A third game, owned by a co-worker, is called London. It is a game about the rebuilding of London after the Great Fire of 1666, though it is much a more abstract city building game than the two other games I discuss here.

I echo many of the complaints about SimCity in the reviews on the site below, but Infinite City is quite good, and there is now an expansion out for it as well.

The SimCity page below does have some suggested rules changes in one of the posts that may improve gameplay, and you can create your own point tracking sheets and markers to speed up calculating costs and benefits as you play new cards. SimCity does take longer and use up more space, and Infinite City is more polished and has nicer looking components. Infinite City may be playable in a longish lunch hour, but SImCity would require a place to leave it up to really get the complete game in lunch time blocks.

I have not played either game enough times to see if historical development patterns are created when you play, but my recollection is that neither SimCity and Infinite City have game rules that really work to incentivize neigborhood/city building as we Planners may see it. There are bonus points for some things (e.g. having a park close to lots of residents), but I don't recall many other rules incentivizing work close to housing close to schools, for example.

http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/3052/sim-city-the-card-game
http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/46807/infinite-city
http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/65781/london

Take a look and see what you think. My nick on boardgamegeek (BGG) is sobegamer, if you're in the DC area, take a look at my collection and lemme know if you want to get together to throw some dice!

Steve Foren, AICP

Prepare for the AICP Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $199
Planetizen Courses image ad

Planetizen Courses

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning professional.
Starting at $14.95 a month
City Plate table setting

New Arrival! City Plates

City downtown cores printed on gorgeous decorative collectible porcelain plates.
$50.00
Women's t-shirt with map of Los Angeles

City T-Shirts for the ladies!

Women's Supersoft CityFabric© Fashion Fit Tees. Now available in six different cities.
$24.00