Architecture You Can Dance To

Tim Halbur's picture
Blogger / Alum
On my way to work this morning, I was listening to an interview with the band Blitzen Trapper on my iPod. They've got a beautiful song called ‘Furr'; the sound echoes 1970s folk rock- and roots influences like English folk, country and bluegrass.  Anyway, Eric Early, the main songwriter, got my attention with his answer to this question:

INTERVIEWER: Obviously ‘American music' means different things to different people. What does it mean to you?

EARLY: I don't know, now I think it sort just means the music that comes out of the environment that we've created. And also I think it comes out of the schism between the environment that we've created, and the environment that was there initially.


One of the things that makes popular music so interesting is the way that it constantly builds on the past to reinvent itself.  Ray Charles famously took gospel music and wedded it to rhythm and blues. The pumping cumbia music of Mexican norteña bands would never have happened if not for Czech and German settlers on the Texas border. And today, a group of producers in Tijuana have combined that same norteña with electronica to create the "Nortec" sound.

Architecture, on the other hand, isn't so good at hybrids, like rock or folk or hip hop. It's more like classical music. The advent of modernism in classical music early in the 20th century created a schism. Dissonance and arrhythmia have dominated the landscape of modern classical music ever since.  Composers who dare to make music that makes reference to the past are usually derided. And so goes architecture.

Our cities and towns are suffering from a schism between the native styles of architecture that made our country unique and a modern style that broke that connection with the "old, weird America", as Greil Marcus put it.  The clean lines of modernism have a tendency to erase our past rather than build upon it, taking our sense of history and place with it.

Modern classical music resembling modern architecture
Modern classical music, with a resemblance to modern architecture.


While I'm not one to reject the modernist style out of hand in architecture (it is responsible for some truly beautiful buildings), it does seem clear that it is not a ‘popular' form.  The audience for modern classical music is small and elite; the same can be said for those who appreciate the rigor of modern architecture, despite the fact that it professes to be a universal, democratic aesthetic.

Meanwhile, many of the attempts to create new versions of American vernacular styles have fallen flat. Particularly in California where the history doesn't run as deep, new buildings engaging with traditional styles are vicitims of too much cost-cutting and cheap imitation in place of true innovation.

So why not? Can we mend the schism between the environment we've created and the environment that was there initially?  Where are the architects with the skill to build upon the styles of the past, and reinvent them with panache? I say, bring back the old, weird America, but make it new again.

Tim Halbur is communications director for the Congress for the New Urbanism (CNU).

Comments

Comments

detritivore design

Yes. Music and Architecture [or simply design thinking] have many corollaries in my world.

Detritivore design focuses on waste, or systems that can benefit from searching and using waste as input. The blog http://wolbert.wordpress.com tracks my development of this design approach.

The band I play with does a mix of originals and covers, from obscure traditional to pop e.g. Blondie and the Cure. We all have day jobs, as sustainable designers or sustainable agriculture farmers but due to distance we really just get together to jam for gigs. This, in my thinking, improves the intention of music as well as collaborative creation. It's not dependency, it's individual identity as it relates to the whole.

All of our separate experiences mean so much more when we finally come back together. We would also do well as a society to stop taking things to the extreme. One can play music as well as pursue a design career. One can be in a band without living in the same city. The important part is to define anchors that give our individual adventures a path.

Architects are beginning to break out of the highly scripted classical music. Maybe we need some more minstrels to visit the variety of design approaches and bring these disparate pieces together. Architecture, as well as America, must be redefined to reflect the diversity, not merely the majority.

Bring back the old

Yes, bring back the old styles of architecture. This is happening more in rural communities than in urban. We have fine architects in this region who build in traditional designs, with long lasting, natural materials. They are expensive and elite to a degree, but at least warm and traditional- as opposed to cold and modern.

Prepare for the AICP Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $199
Planetizen Courses image ad

Planetizen Courses

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning professional.
Starting at $14.95 a month
City Plate table setting

New Arrival! City Plates

City downtown cores printed on gorgeous decorative collectible porcelain plates.
$50.00
poster

A Short History of America

From comic book artist Robert Crumb, poster shows how the built environment has changed throughout the decades.
$14.95