Navigating by Intuition

Lisa Feldstein's picture
Blogger

As a lifelong urbanite, I've always felt comfortable learning cities "by Braille." I put on my walking shoes and wander, making mental maps as I go. I experience serendipity, yet can generally intuit where things are likely to be – the CBD, the government center, nightlife.

This summer our family spent time in Berlin, Venice, Florence, and Paris. Of the four, Paris was the only one I'd been to before. By the time we got there, it was like greeting an old friend.

Berlin is a fantastic city for many reasons, a remarkable blend of modern sophistication and livability. I also "grokked" it – navigating the city was easy, in no small part because of its terrific public transit and very walkable neighborhoods.But deeper than that, the city made sense to me at a visceral level.

Venice was harder, but I experienced it spatially as a puzzle. As we got lost in alleys three cobblestones wide, I contemplated both the audacity of building such a place and how different the medieval mind must have been. If cities are concretization of place and time, then Venice seemed farther removed from my daily experience than any place I'd encountered in India or Latin America.

Then we came to Florence, and for the first time I was confronted with a place that I couldn't comprehend.  The square on which our apartment was located – Santo Spirito – was lovely, with a daily market that changed subtly with the days of the week. The rest of the city, however, felt like a museum of itself. Most Florentines live in the suburbs, having abandoned the city proper to the hoards of tourists who descend upon it each summer. For those who come to worship at the temple of Dante or take in art at the Uffizi until they go cross-eyed, Florence is a rich place. And certainly Tuscan food and wine are sufficient distraction for anyone. Yet for those of us who travel to experience place, Florence is disappointing.

Arriving in Paris felt as though we had come back through the looking glass. It was legible; I could find my way once again. I still had my sight, but more importantly, my sense of touch was returned to me.

What makes places legible for you?

Lisa Feldstein seeks to use land use as a tool for social and economic justice.

Comments

Comments

Kevin Lynch wrote

Kevin Lynch wrote extensively on this subject in "Image of the City". Think about the way in which you would give somebody directions in your own town; based mainly on landmarks, with a few street names and maybe a house number mixed in, right?

It's easy to perceive these context clues in cities that have evolved over hundreds of years. How can we design newer places for clarity of organization, while also providing enough character to trigger visual/mental orientation?

Lisa Feldstein's picture
Blogger

I've read Lynch, but I'm not

I've read Lynch, but I'm not sure I agree with your point. I couldn't find the context clues in Florence, hard as I looked for them. It was a strange feeling; I'd never really been in a city where I couldn't find a point of entry for navigation.

I do agree that this can be a problem with newer places, where efficiency can trump clarity.

Good point about Florence.

Good point about Florence. While all the historic stuff is lovely and rightfully attracts hordes of tourists, Florence (Firenze) is hard to fathom on the ground. It’s a bit suffocating. There are precious few places where vistas open up to give a sense of direction. There are numerous piazzas scattered throughout the centre of the city, but they are quite small and claustrophobic with four and five-storey buildings crowding in closely on all sides. Only from Piazza Michelangelo which sits atop a hill on the opposite bank of the Arno, does one finally see the city spread out below, giving off a refreshing sense of freedom (to me at least) from the masonry jungle below. I wouldn’t go so far as to say the city disappoints, but it has a very different feeling from places like Paris or Berlin.

chrisinsobe

Prepare for the AICP Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $199
Planetizen Courses image ad

Planetizen Courses

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning professional.
Starting at $14.95 a month
Women's t-shirt with map of Los Angeles

City T-Shirts for the ladies!

Women's Supersoft CityFabric© Fashion Fit Tees. Now available in six different cities.
$24.00

Wear your city with style!

100% silk scarves feature detailed city maps. Choose from six cities with red or blue trim.
$55.00